Discipline Committees make findings about misconduct. Complaints screening bodies deal with concerns. Concerns may require no action, may warrant remedial measures that would benefit the registrant’s future practice, or may warrant a formal determination at discipline. This distinction is legally important.
For example, at a discipline hearing, a finding that a registrant fell below the standard of practice of the profession usually requires expert evidence. It is seen as unfair for a disciplinary panel to rely on its own expertise in that regard. There are some exceptions, such as where the standard is set out in a regulation or where the standard is obvious. However, the same is not usually true for complaints screening bodies. Since no finding of misconduct is made and much less is at stake for the registrant, a complaints screening body can generally rely on its own expertise.
In Tupman v. Ontario (Health Professions Appeal and Review Board), 2026 ONSC 6168 (CanLII), a patient complained that a dentist had an insufficient basis to recommend the restoration of five of her teeth. The complaints screening committee, called the Inquiries, Complaints and Reports Committee (ICRC), was composed of a public member and two dentists who reviewed the radiographs. The ICRC had concerns that the dentist did not have clinical justification to recommend the restoration of five teeth, that there had been an inadequate assessment (an explorer had not been used in diagnosing the patient’s cavities), and that there was inadequate documentation to support the dentist’s diagnoses. Without obtaining an expert opinion , the ICRC directed the registrant to complete a remedial program at his own expense. Both the Review Board and the Divisional Court (on judicial review) found that the ICRC’s decision was reasonable.
On the distinction between findings of professional misconduct and the presence of concerns, the Divisional Court considered whether the screening committee’s concerns were “justifiable”, and said:
But issues of malpractice and failing to meet the standard of care played no part in the ICRC conclusions…. The ICRC had concerns and it directed that the applicant take a [remediation program]. At the end of the day, the ICRC reasonably expressed and explained its concerns on these issues. It is only the reasonableness of the concerns that is at issue here.
On the need for expert evidence, the Divisional Court said:
The applicant asserts that the ICRC should have sought expert evidence to resolve the disputed positions of the applicant and the second opinion dentist about the diagnosis and treatment of decay. The ICRC panel included dentists with knowledge of their profession. The Supreme Court has explained that a reviewing court must be mindful and respectful of the tribunal’s competence within its own field of expertise: Vavilov, at paras. 89-93. Accordingly, this court has deferred to the expertise of members of the ICRC in determining what is relevant to its investigation and whether expert evidence needs to be secured…. That the ICRC did not seek additional expert evidence is not a hallmark of unreasonableness.
Other points of interest in the Court’s decision include:
- In terms of the Review Board’s role, the Court said: “Importantly, an HPARB review is not a fresh or further investigation into the complaint. It is not a hearing. No witnesses are called, no experts are qualified, no evidence is admitted as at a hearing. There are no exhibits, and no questioning or cross-examination… the HPARB’s mandate on a review is to consider the adequacy of the ICRC investigation, and/or the reasonableness of its decision.”
- On the review before HPARB, the dentist tendered an expert report supporting his approach to the patient. The report had not been provided to the complaints screening body. The Court held that a review of the reasonableness of the complaints screening body’s decision should be based on the information before it at the time and not on additional evidence. The expert report could only be used to assist in determining whether the screening body’s investigation had been adequate: “The HPARB properly limited the use of the Prakki report to the issue of the adequacy of the investigation and reasonably found that the ICRC investigation was adequate, even though it did not seek an expert opinion.”
The distinction between findings of misconduct and justifiable concerns is significant.